NYCCGC Responds to Parks Rules

On October 13, 2010, NYC Department of Parks & Recreation's "new rules" for community gardens under their jurisdiction went into effect. After listening to the voices of our members and allies from across the city at our monthly meetings and at a special Town Hall Meeting convened in early October at The New School, NYCCGC has some crucial suggestions for improving current and future rules, regulations, and legislation to protect our city's vibrant community gardens.


New York City Community Garden Coalition’s Response
to NYC Dept. of Parks and Recreation’s Rules* for Community Gardens

* New Chapter 6 of Title 56 of the Official Compilation of Rules of the City of New York

New York City Community Garden Coalition (NYCCGC) was at the table during the initial process of drafting the new Parks Department rules concerning community gardens, and we look forward to being involved in the drafting of future policies and legislation that will permanently preserve our city’s vibrant community gardens, and create opportunities for the development of more. We are glad to see the rules state that any community garden under the Parks Department will remain so if these rules are followed. However, NYCCGC has several concerns about the new rules, identified by our leadership, members, and legal counsel. We believe our recommendations, detailed below, would offer better support for community gardens, and, going forward, request their adoption into the rules, procedures, policies, and legislation regarding community gardens.


PART I - Create Transparent Processes for Gardens in “Default” and “Accelerated Default”

NYCCGC is concerned about what criteria the Department of Parks & Recreation (DPR) uses to determine that a garden is in “default” or “accelerated default.” For example, according to the rules, a garden is in accelerated default if it "affects, or poses a threat to the health or safety of the community in which the Lot and Garden are located." The rules do not provide any criteria as to what will determine this violation. There is no clear notification process for a gardening group to learn that DPR considers its activities to "affect... the health or safety of the community.” By the time that group receives a notice of default, according to the DPR rules, it has only 30 days to cure the perceived problem.

1.) Form an Advisory Group to Clarify and Correct Persistent Violations

We recommend that a GreenThumb advisory group be formed, with community gardeners  as a majority of members. This group would deal with violations and could include NYCCGC, and other community and greening groups, to work directly with individual gardening groups and gardeners to correct violations that have persisted and may lead to a default. This group would need guidelines; documented criteria for default and accelerated default.

2.) Form a Review Panel for Transparent Processes and Decisions on Default:

Under the current rules, the final determination of default is at the sole discretion of the DPR’s Commissioner. To create a transparent process before the Commissioner’s determination, we recommend a panel of three individuals be formed to hold an evidentiary hearing to arrive at a recommendation for action. One of the individuals would be chosen by DPR, another chosen by community gardeners, and the third person would be someone mutually agreed upon by both DPR and community gardeners. The Commissioner would then accept or reject the panel's determination. In the event that the Commissioner rejects the panel's decision, a court could review if the rejection was proper. There is precedent for successful implementation of such a system at administrative agencies in the past.

3.) Create a Dedicated Website to Inform Gardeners and the Community

We recommend that GreenThumb establish a dedicated public website where notifications to community gardens are posted. Automated alerts regarding infractions could be sent via a RSS "web feed" subscription. GreenThumb would publish and post persistent violations 30 days after the infraction, as well as individual community garden default notifications. Notices of garden default should also be mailed and emailed to all members of the garden group as registered with GreenThumb.

PART II - Identify All Permanently Protected Community Gardens

It is NYCCGC's contention that all gardens listed in the "Offer for Preservation" section of the NY State Attorney General’s 2002 Community Garden Agreement are permanently protected by that document. We request a fully documented list of actions on all community gardens listed by the Agreement. This includes the 198 community gardens listed in the agreement, as well as those which were later transferred, swapped, and added to the list after 2002.

PART III - Collectively Forge New Legislation and Policy

NYCCGC is mindful that the DPR rules cover only community gardens that are under DPR. Other gardens fall under the jurisdiction of many other agencies, including Housing Preservation & Development, Department of Education, Department of Transportation, and New York City Housing Authority, and are not covered by these rules. We are very excited to be working in a truly shared process with Speaker Quinn, Parks Council Chair Viverito, and the Mayor’s office to create legislation and policies extending permanent protections and support to all current and future community gardens and urban farms. Our collaboration will provide the neighborhoods in our city with all the beauty and improved quality of life that nature provides, as well as access to nutritious, locally-grown food, opportunities for recreation, therapy, exercise, education, and inter-generational and cross-cultural connections.